{
  "claim": "Načrtovana je novogradnja enostanovanjske stavbe etažnosti P (pritličje).",
  "verdict": {
    "label": "insufficient evidence",
    "probability": 0.567,
    "shown": {
      "text": "insufficient evidence, 0.57"
    }
  },
  "flags": [
    "'norm:r1|land_use:M:SK' in zone:M:EUP1: not this project's case: its condition “slemenska naselja” does not hold (supplied: place line 8 “zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement”): The plan classifies unit EUP1 as a valley settlement, not a ridge settlement. The ridge-settlement case therefore does not apply.",
    "'norm:r2|act:opn' in zone:M:EUP1: not this project's case: its condition “na ravninskem terenu, če predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in ni porušen višinski videz naselja” does not hold (assumption): The exception requires the building to be a characteristic settlement accent on flat terrain. An ordinary ground-floor-only (P) single-family house is not such an accent unless its documentation presents it as one, and the documentation given does not. The conjunction therefore fails whatever the terrain. Needs: Whether the DGD presents the building as a characteristic settlement accent (značilni naselbinski poudarek), whether the terrain is flat, and whether the settlement's height profile stays intact.",
    "'norm:r3|act:opn' in zone:M:EUP1: not this project's case: its condition “teren ali tla ne omogočajo podkletitve” does not hold (assumption): Nothing given says the terrain or ground rules out a basement. The usual case is that a basement is possible unless a geotechnical finding says otherwise. The project is plain P and does not invoke this exception. Needs: A geotechnical or geomechanical report, or a statement in the DGD, on whether the terrain or ground at the parcel allows a basement.",
    "weak evidence: most of the mass is uncertainty",
    "norm: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen requires ≤ (K)+P+(1N) (zone:M:EUP1): claimed p: meets"
  ],
  "norm": {
    "applies": "yes",
    "applies_reason": "the site lies wholly in zone:M:EUP1, where the norm is in force on 2022-12-31, and its condition holds for the project",
    "as_of": "2022-12-31",
    "assumptions": [
      "as of 2022-12-31: the documentation's date, the filing date being unknown (an assumption)",
      "version in force on 2022-12-31: opn version 1 (valid 2021-08-23–)",
      "extraction state: the rule was extracted from the provision by a model and not reviewed by a planner (unvalidated): counted at reliability 0.7",
      "condition: “dolinska naselja” holds (supplied: place line 8 “zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement”): The parcel lies wholly in unit EUP1, and the plan classifies EUP1 as a valley settlement (dolinsko naselje). (a model's application of the provision to the project, not the record)",
      "not this project's case, assumed: 'norm:r2|act:opn': its condition “na ravninskem terenu, če predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in ni porušen višinski videz naselja” does not hold (assumption): The exception requires the building to be a characteristic settlement accent on flat terrain. An ordinary ground-floor-only (P) single-family house is not such an accent unless its documentation presents it as one, and the documentation given does not. The conjunction therefore fails whatever the terrain. Needs: Whether the DGD presents the building as a characteristic settlement accent (značilni naselbinski poudarek), whether the terrain is flat, and whether the settlement's height profile stays intact.",
      "not this project's case, assumed: 'norm:r3|act:opn': its condition “teren ali tla ne omogočajo podkletitve” does not hold (assumption): Nothing given says the terrain or ground rules out a basement. The usual case is that a basement is possible unless a geotechnical finding says otherwise. The project is plain P and does not invoke this exception. Needs: A geotechnical or geomechanical report, or a statement in the DGD, on whether the terrain or ground at the parcel allows a basement.",
      "measurement convention: height measured as the provision measures it (from the terrain unless it says otherwise)",
      "the site lies under the protective regime vvo:3: its consents and conditions apply on top of this norm",
      "the site lies under the protective regime erosion:usual: its consents and conditions apply on top of this norm",
      "the site lies under the protective regime road_belt:public-path: its consents and conditions apply on top of this norm",
      "the site lies under the protective regime agri:grassland: its consents and conditions apply on top of this norm",
      "comparison in words: a model read the provision against the claim (expert evidence, never the record): The provision sets a maximum ('do največ') of (K) + P + (1N), where the basement (K) and one upper floor (1N) are optional. A building with only a ground floor (P) is below that maximum. — This line governs only if Juršinci, or the part containing planning unit EUP1, is a valley settlement. The ridge-settlement line [0] also allows P, so the claim meets the storey requirement either way. No reading is given because the requirement is a storey profile, not a single number. The 0.2 m limit for the knee wall ('kolenčni zid') is a separate factor and is not judged here. — applies unclear: This line of Article 84 covers only valley settlements ('dolinska naselja'). Neither the site description nor the provision says whether Juršinci (planning unit EUP1, SK) is a valley settlement or a ridge settlement."
    ],
    "cite_as": {
      "en": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen",
      "lang": "sl",
      "text": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen"
    },
    "condition_checks": [
      {
        "basis": "supplied",
        "cite": "place line 8",
        "condition": "dolinska naselja",
        "holds": true,
        "norm": "norm:r4|land_use:M:SK",
        "quote": "zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement",
        "reason": "The parcel lies wholly in unit EUP1, and the plan classifies EUP1 as a valley settlement (dolinsko naselje).",
        "rule": "zone:M:EUP1|norm_condition:d1d34921be"
      },
      {
        "basis": "supplied",
        "cite": "place line 8",
        "condition": "slemenska naselja",
        "holds": false,
        "norm": "norm:r1|land_use:M:SK",
        "quote": "zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement",
        "reason": "The plan classifies unit EUP1 as a valley settlement, not a ridge settlement. The ridge-settlement case therefore does not apply.",
        "rule": "zone:M:EUP1|norm_condition:4dcd2dd078"
      },
      {
        "basis": "assumption",
        "condition": "na ravninskem terenu, če predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in ni porušen višinski videz naselja",
        "holds": false,
        "norm": "norm:r2|act:opn",
        "reason": "The exception requires the building to be a characteristic settlement accent on flat terrain. An ordinary ground-floor-only (P) single-family house is not such an accent unless its documentation presents it as one, and the documentation given does not. The conjunction therefore fails whatever the terrain. Needs: Whether the DGD presents the building as a characteristic settlement accent (značilni naselbinski poudarek), whether the terrain is flat, and whether the settlement's height profile stays intact.",
        "rule": "site:example|norm_condition:bc348ac9d9"
      },
      {
        "basis": "assumption",
        "condition": "teren ali tla ne omogočajo podkletitve",
        "holds": false,
        "norm": "norm:r3|act:opn",
        "reason": "Nothing given says the terrain or ground rules out a basement. The usual case is that a basement is possible unless a geotechnical finding says otherwise. The project is plain P and does not invoke this exception. Needs: A geotechnical or geomechanical report, or a statement in the DGD, on whether the terrain or ground at the parcel allows a basement.",
        "rule": "zone:M:EUP1|norm_condition:46b9f67ef6"
      }
    ],
    "considered": [
      {
        "cite_as": {
          "en": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen"
        },
        "decision": "decisive",
        "outcome": "meets",
        "required": "≤ (K)+P+(1N)",
        "requirement": {
          "en": "v dolinskih naseljih do največ (K) + P + (1N) s kolenčnim zidom do 0,2 m.",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "v dolinskih naseljih do največ (K) + P + (1N) s kolenčnim zidom do 0,2 m."
        },
        "rule": "norm:r4|land_use:M:SK",
        "share": 1.0,
        "source_rule": "r4",
        "status": "decisive",
        "zone": "zone:M:EUP1"
      },
      {
        "cite_as": {
          "en": "Decree on the Municipal Spatial Plan of the Municipality of Juršinci (Official Gazette of the Municipality of Juršinci, No. 3/14), Article 52",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 52. člen"
        },
        "decision": "overridden",
        "outcome": "meets",
        "required": "≤ (K)+P+1N",
        "requirement": {
          "en": "for buildings with a storey configuration of (K) + P + 1N, permissible on level terrain",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "pri objektih z etažnostjo (K) + P + 1N, dopustnih na ravninskem terenu"
        },
        "rule": "norm:r5|act:opn",
        "share": 1.0,
        "source_rule": "r5",
        "status": "overridden by a more specific norm",
        "zone": "zone:M:EUP1"
      },
      {
        "cite_as": {
          "en": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 51. člen",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 51. člen"
        },
        "decision": "overridden",
        "outcome": "not compared",
        "required": "≤ (K)+P+(M)",
        "requirement": {
          "en": "etažnosti (K) + P + (M), s kolenčnim zidom do višine 1 m",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "etažnosti (K) + P + (M), s kolenčnim zidom do višine 1 m"
        },
        "rule": "norm:r6|act:opn",
        "share": 1.0,
        "source_rule": "r6",
        "status": "overridden by a more specific norm",
        "zone": "zone:M:EUP1"
      },
      {
        "cite_as": {
          "en": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 51. člen",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 51. člen"
        },
        "decision": "overridden",
        "outcome": "not compared",
        "required": "not povišanje etažnosti",
        "requirement": {
          "en": "ni pa povišanje etažnosti dopustno pri nestanovanjskih kmetijskih stavbah",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "ni pa povišanje etažnosti dopustno pri nestanovanjskih kmetijskih stavbah"
        },
        "rule": "norm:r7|act:opn",
        "share": 1.0,
        "source_rule": "r7",
        "status": "overridden by a more specific norm",
        "zone": "zone:M:EUP1"
      },
      {
        "cite_as": {
          "en": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen"
        },
        "decision": "not_its_case",
        "outcome": "meets",
        "required": "≤ (K)+P+(M)",
        "requirement": {
          "en": "v slemenskih naseljih (K) + P + (M) s kolenčnim zidom do 1 m;",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "v slemenskih naseljih (K) + P + (M) s kolenčnim zidom do 1 m;"
        },
        "rule": "norm:r1|land_use:M:SK",
        "share": 1.0,
        "source_rule": "r1",
        "status": "not this project's case: its condition “slemenska naselja” does not hold (supplied: place line 8 “zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement”): The plan classifies unit EUP1 as a valley settlement, not a ridge settlement. The ridge-settlement case therefore does not apply.",
        "zone": "zone:M:EUP1"
      },
      {
        "cite_as": {
          "en": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 51. člen",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 51. člen"
        },
        "decision": "not_its_case",
        "outcome": "not compared",
        "required": "≤ (K)+P+(1N)",
        "requirement": {
          "en": "na ravninskem terenu je dopustno povišanje etažnosti stavb do (K) + P + (1N), s kolenčnim zidom do 0,2 m, če povišanje etažnosti predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in s tem ni porušen višinski videz naselja",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "na ravninskem terenu je dopustno povišanje etažnosti stavb do (K) + P + (1N), s kolenčnim zidom do 0,2 m, če povišanje etažnosti predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in s tem ni porušen višinski videz naselja"
        },
        "rule": "norm:r2|act:opn",
        "share": 1.0,
        "source_rule": "r2",
        "status": "not this project's case: its condition “na ravninskem terenu, če predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in ni porušen višinski videz naselja” does not hold (assumption): The exception requires the building to be a characteristic settlement accent on flat terrain. An ordinary ground-floor-only (P) single-family house is not such an accent unless its documentation presents it as one, and the documentation given does not. The conjunction therefore fails whatever the terrain. Needs: Whether the DGD presents the building as a characteristic settlement accent (značilni naselbinski poudarek), whether the terrain is flat, and whether the settlement's height profile stays intact.",
        "zone": "zone:M:EUP1"
      },
      {
        "cite_as": {
          "en": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 51. člen",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 51. člen"
        },
        "decision": "not_its_case",
        "outcome": "not compared",
        "required": "not povišanje stavbe",
        "requirement": {
          "en": "v primeru, da nagib terena, stabilnost tal, nosilnost tal ali višina podtalnice ne omogoča podkletitve stavbe, povišanje stavbe ni dopustno",
          "lang": "sl",
          "text": "v primeru, da nagib terena, stabilnost tal, nosilnost tal ali višina podtalnice ne omogoča podkletitve stavbe, povišanje stavbe ni dopustno"
        },
        "rule": "norm:r3|act:opn",
        "share": 1.0,
        "source_rule": "r3",
        "status": "not this project's case: its condition “teren ali tla ne omogočajo podkletitve” does not hold (assumption): Nothing given says the terrain or ground rules out a basement. The usual case is that a basement is possible unless a geotechnical finding says otherwise. The project is plain P and does not invoke this exception. Needs: A geotechnical or geomechanical report, or a statement in the DGD, on whether the terrain or ground at the parcel allows a basement.",
        "zone": "zone:M:EUP1"
      }
    ],
    "factor": "storeys",
    "locus": {
      "cite_as": {
        "en": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen",
        "lang": "sl",
        "text": "Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen"
      },
      "corpus": "luma",
      "document": "opn",
      "domain": "si-building",
      "state": "unvalidated",
      "support": "verbatim",
      "unit": "84",
      "url": "<the plan's page in PIS>",
      "version": "1"
    },
    "requirement": {
      "en": "v dolinskih naseljih do največ (K) + P + (1N) s kolenčnim zidom do 0,2 m.",
      "lang": "sl",
      "text": "v dolinskih naseljih do največ (K) + P + (1N) s kolenčnim zidom do 0,2 m."
    },
    "rule": "norm:r4|land_use:M:SK",
    "state": "unvalidated",
    "status": "meets",
    "status_text": "meets the norm",
    "url": "<the plan's page in PIS>",
    "value_claimed": "p",
    "value_required": "≤ (K)+P+(1N)"
  },
  "derivation": {
    "claim": 1,
    "depth": 1,
    "grounds": [
      {
        "grounding": "statute",
        "label": "insufficient evidence",
        "predicate": "storeys:p",
        "probability": 0.567,
        "sources": [
          "statute: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 52. člen <the plan's page in PIS> (2026-10-26)",
          "statute: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen <the plan's page in PIS> (2026-10-28)",
          "statute: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen <the plan's page in PIS> (2021-08-23)"
        ],
        "subject": "site:example"
      },
      {
        "grounding": "supplied",
        "label": "holds",
        "predicate": "condition “dolinska naselja”",
        "probability": 1.0,
        "sources": [
          "supplied: place line 8 “zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement”; The parcel lies wholly in unit EUP1, and the plan classifies EUP1 as a valley settlement (dolinsko naselje)."
        ],
        "subject": "site:example"
      },
      {
        "grounding": "supplied",
        "label": "does not hold",
        "predicate": "condition “slemenska naselja”",
        "probability": 0.0,
        "sources": [
          "supplied: place line 8 “zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement”; The plan classifies unit EUP1 as a valley settlement, not a ridge settlement. The ridge-settlement case therefore does not apply."
        ],
        "subject": "site:example"
      }
    ],
    "presumptions": [
      "site:example condition “na ravninskem terenu, če predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in ni porušen višinski videz naselja”",
      "site:example condition “teren ali tla ne omogočajo podkletitve”"
    ],
    "rendering": "#1 “Načrtovana je novogradnja enostanovanjske stavbe etažnosti P (pritličje).”\nsite:example storeys:p: insufficient evidence, 0.57 [statute]\n  · statute: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 52. člen <the plan's page in PIS> (2026-10-26)\n  · statute: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen <the plan's page in PIS> (2026-10-28)\n  · statute: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen <the plan's page in PIS> (2021-08-23)\n  + site:example condition “dolinska naselja” (fact): holds [supplied]\n    · supplied: place line 8 “zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement”; The parcel lies wholly in unit EUP1, and the plan classifies EUP1 as a valley settlement (dolinsko naselje).\n  − site:example condition “slemenska naselja” (fact): does not hold: 'norm:r1|land_use:M:SK' is not this project's case [supplied]\n    · supplied: place line 8 “zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement”; The plan classifies unit EUP1 as a valley settlement, not a ridge settlement. The ridge-settlement case therefore does not apply.\n  − site:example condition “na ravninskem terenu, če predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in ni porušen višinski videz naselja” (fact): does not hold: 'norm:r2|act:opn' is not this project's case [assumption]\n    · assumption: The exception requires the building to be a characteristic settlement accent on flat terrain. An ordinary ground-floor-only (P) single-family house is not such an accent unless its documentation presents it as one, and the documentation given does not. The conjunction therefore fails whatever the terrain. Needs: Whether the DGD presents the building as a characteristic settlement accent (značilni naselbinski poudarek), whether the terrain is flat, and whether the settlement's height profile stays intact.\n  − site:example condition “teren ali tla ne omogočajo podkletitve” (fact): does not hold: 'norm:r3|act:opn' is not this project's case [assumption]\n    · assumption: Nothing given says the terrain or ground rules out a basement. The usual case is that a basement is possible unless a geotechnical finding says otherwise. The project is plain P and does not invoke this exception. Needs: A geotechnical or geomechanical report, or a statement in the DGD, on whether the terrain or ground at the parcel allows a basement.\ngrounds: 3; judgements: none; open: none\npresumed or assumed (holds unless shown otherwise): site:example condition “na ravninskem terenu, če predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in ni porušen višinski videz naselja”, site:example condition “teren ali tla ne omogočajo podkletitve”\n",
    "root": {
      "children": [
        {
          "grounding": "supplied",
          "kind": "fact",
          "label": "holds",
          "predicate": "condition “dolinska naselja”",
          "probability": 1.0,
          "shown": "holds",
          "sources": [
            "supplied: place line 8 “zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement”; The parcel lies wholly in unit EUP1, and the plan classifies EUP1 as a valley settlement (dolinsko naselje)."
          ],
          "subject": "site:example",
          "supports": true
        },
        {
          "grounding": "supplied",
          "kind": "fact",
          "label": "does not hold",
          "predicate": "condition “slemenska naselja”",
          "probability": 0.0,
          "shown": "does not hold: 'norm:r1|land_use:M:SK' is not this project's case",
          "sources": [
            "supplied: place line 8 “zone:M:EUP1 is_classified_as:valley_settlement”; The plan classifies unit EUP1 as a valley settlement, not a ridge settlement. The ridge-settlement case therefore does not apply."
          ],
          "subject": "site:example",
          "supports": false
        },
        {
          "grounding": "assumption",
          "kind": "fact",
          "label": "does not hold",
          "predicate": "condition “na ravninskem terenu, če predstavlja značilne naselbinske poudarke in ni porušen višinski videz naselja”",
          "probability": 0.0,
          "shown": "does not hold: 'norm:r2|act:opn' is not this project's case",
          "sources": [
            "assumption: The exception requires the building to be a characteristic settlement accent on flat terrain. An ordinary ground-floor-only (P) single-family house is not such an accent unless its documentation presents it as one, and the documentation given does not. The conjunction therefore fails whatever the terrain. Needs: Whether the DGD presents the building as a characteristic settlement accent (značilni naselbinski poudarek), whether the terrain is flat, and whether the settlement's height profile stays intact."
          ],
          "subject": "site:example",
          "supports": false
        },
        {
          "grounding": "assumption",
          "kind": "fact",
          "label": "does not hold",
          "predicate": "condition “teren ali tla ne omogočajo podkletitve”",
          "probability": 0.0,
          "shown": "does not hold: 'norm:r3|act:opn' is not this project's case",
          "sources": [
            "assumption: Nothing given says the terrain or ground rules out a basement. The usual case is that a basement is possible unless a geotechnical finding says otherwise. The project is plain P and does not invoke this exception. Needs: A geotechnical or geomechanical report, or a statement in the DGD, on whether the terrain or ground at the parcel allows a basement."
          ],
          "subject": "site:example",
          "supports": false
        }
      ],
      "grounding": "statute",
      "label": "insufficient evidence",
      "predicate": "storeys:p",
      "probability": 0.567,
      "shown": "insufficient evidence, 0.57",
      "sources": [
        "statute: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 52. člen <the plan's page in PIS> (2026-10-26)",
        "statute: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen <the plan's page in PIS> (2026-10-28)",
        "statute: Odlok o občinskem prostorskem načrtu občine Juršinci (Uradni vestnik Občine Juršinci, št. 3/14), 84. člen <the plan's page in PIS> (2021-08-23)"
      ],
      "subject": "site:example"
    },
    "text": "Načrtovana je novogradnja enostanovanjske stavbe etažnosti P (pritličje)."
  }
}